{"entity":{"id":6905,"slug":"fourth-circuit-court-of-appeals","name":"Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals","type":"institution","role":"Federal appellate court that upheld the $42 million verdict against CACI in March 2026","description":null,"imageUrl":null,"createdAt":"2026-04-14T01:15:46.155Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-19T09:24:31.530Z"},"electedOffice":null,"significance":{"score":9,"components":{"totalFindings":0,"connectionDegree":8,"recentFindings90d":0,"activeResearchJobs":0,"goblinAttributions":1,"recentSyntheses90d":0,"moneyFlowChainsTotal":0,"closedLoopMemberships":0,"moneyFlowHopsRecent90d":0},"computedAt":"2026-10-18T01:35:55.060Z"},"facts":[],"connections":[{"id":19567,"relationshipType":"contract database","description":"Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals may have contracts listed in SAM.gov, which is the System for Award Management database, but no specific contracts were found in the search results.","confidence":"inferential","firstDocumented":"2026","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":3283,"name":"SAM.gov","slug":"sam-gov","type":"institution"}},{"id":12167,"relationshipType":"Appellate court","description":"This court is listed in the entity list following the plaintiff group and attorneys, indicating it is the appellate court that heard appeals in cases involving Suhail Najim Abdullah Al Shimari.","confidence":"inferential","firstDocumented":"2006","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6886,"name":"Suhail Najim Abdullah Al Shimari","slug":"suhail-najim-abdullah-al-shimari","type":"person"}},{"id":12123,"relationshipType":"legal","description":"Appeals involving CACI, Inc. - Federal and Abu Ghraib torture claims were heard by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, as indicated by the known entities list referencing this court and the case.","confidence":"inferential","firstDocumented":"2008","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6878,"name":"CACI, Inc. - Federal","slug":"caci-inc-federal","type":"company"}},{"id":12291,"relationshipType":"legal","description":"Timothy Dugan served as legal counsel in cases before the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals involving Ibrahim v. Titan Corp.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2006","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6890,"name":"Timothy Dugan","slug":"timothy-dugan","type":"person"}},{"id":12290,"relationshipType":"legal","description":"Baher Azmy served as legal counsel in cases before the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals involving Ibrahim v. Titan Corp.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2006","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6893,"name":"Baher Azmy","slug":"baher-azmy","type":"person"}},{"id":12289,"relationshipType":"legal","description":"L-3 Services was involved in litigation before the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals related to the Titan Corp. cases (Ibrahim v. Titan Corp. and Saleh v. Titan).","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2006","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6901,"name":"L-3 Services","slug":"l-3-services","type":"company"}},{"id":12288,"relationshipType":"legal","description":"Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP represented defendants in cases against Titan Corp. that were appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2006","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6900,"name":"Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP","slug":"patterson-belknap-webb-tyler-llp","type":"company"}},{"id":12287,"relationshipType":"legal","description":"Akeel & Valentine, PLC represented plaintiffs in cases against Titan Corp. that were appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2006","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6899,"name":"Akeel & Valentine, PLC","slug":"akeel-valentine-plc","type":"company"}},{"id":12286,"relationshipType":"colleague","description":"Judge Floyd served on the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals panel that heard the cases Ibrahim v. Titan Corp. and Saleh v. Titan.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2006","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6897,"name":"Judge Floyd","slug":"judge-floyd","type":"person"}},{"id":12274,"relationshipType":"appellate_review","description":"The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia is a federal trial court whose decisions are appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2026","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6904,"name":"U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia","slug":"u-s-district-court-for-the-eastern-district-of-virginia","type":"institution"}},{"id":12273,"relationshipType":"Appellate court","description":"The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals handled appeals related to Saleh v. Titan, indicating the case proceeded beyond the district court level.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2005","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6903,"name":"Saleh v. Titan","slug":"saleh-v-titan","type":"instrument"}},{"id":12270,"relationshipType":"appeals court","description":"The case was appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, which is listed in the known entities database directly below Ibrahim v. Titan Corp.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2025","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6902,"name":"Ibrahim v. Titan Corp.","slug":"ibrahim-v-titan-corp","type":"instrument"}},{"id":12261,"relationshipType":"judicial_appointment","description":"Judge Stephanie D. Thacker is a judge on the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2022","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6898,"name":"Judge Stephanie D. Thacker","slug":"judge-stephanie-d-thacker","type":"person"}},{"id":12251,"relationshipType":"judicial hierarchy connection","description":"Judge Gerald Bruce Lee's rulings from the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia would be under the appellate jurisdiction of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, which is listed in connection with cases involving Lee.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2026","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6895,"name":"Judge Gerald Bruce Lee","slug":"judge-gerald-bruce-lee","type":"person"}},{"id":12249,"relationshipType":"legal venue","description":"Appeals in cases involving Michael Buchanan were heard in the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"Unknown","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6894,"name":"Michael Buchanan","slug":"michael-buchanan","type":"person"}},{"id":12232,"relationshipType":"court_appearance","description":"Muhammad Faridi appeared before the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals in connection with the Ibrahim v. Titan Corp. appeals.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2026","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6892,"name":"Muhammad Faridi","slug":"muhammad-faridi","type":"person"}},{"id":12221,"relationshipType":"legal venue","description":"Katherine Gallagher's cases were appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, as indicated by the presence of judges from that court in the entity list associated with her name.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2000","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6891,"name":"Katherine Gallagher","slug":"katherine-gallagher","type":"person"}},{"id":12204,"relationshipType":"Appellate venue","description":"John Gleeson is identified as an appellant or appellee in cases appealed from the Eastern District of Virginia to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals involving contractor liability for torture.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2008","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6934,"name":"John Gleeson","slug":"john-gleeson","type":"person"}},{"id":12186,"relationshipType":"appellate jurisdiction","description":"Appeals in the cases involving Taha Yaseen Arraq Rashid (Ibrahim v. Titan Corp., Saleh v. Titan) were heard by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2005","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6889,"name":"Taha Yaseen Arraq Rashid","slug":"taha-yaseen-arraq-rashid","type":"person"}},{"id":12173,"relationshipType":"Appellate jurisdiction","description":"Al-Ejaili's case Saleh v. Titan was appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.","confidence":"primary","firstDocumented":"2006","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6888,"name":"Salah Hasan Nusaif Al-Ejaili","slug":"salah-hasan-nusaif-al-ejaili","type":"person"}},{"id":12256,"relationshipType":"appeals court","description":"Judge Brinkema's rulings in cases like Ibrahim v. Titan Corp. were subject to appeal before the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.","confidence":"secondary","firstDocumented":"2005","lastDocumented":null,"other":{"id":6896,"name":"Judge Leonie Brinkema","slug":"judge-leonie-brinkema","type":"person"}}],"contradictions":[],"permalink":"https://www.goblinhouse.net/entity/fourth-circuit-court-of-appeals","timelineUrl":"https://www.goblinhouse.net/entity/fourth-circuit-court-of-appeals/timeline"}