Said vs. did

What they said, against what the record shows

Every entry pairs a person's own words, dated and sourced, with the record that followed: a filing, a vote, a disclosure, a court position. Five kinds of pairing live in one ledger. Filter by kind, or search a name. For one person's positions over time, see By person.

51entries
35people and companies
5kinds of pairing

Contradictions: a stated position, then a sourced action that points the other way.

4 entries
Contradiction Bill Hagerty Career Jun 15, 2024
Hagerty's seat on Senate Banking is framed as oversight of stablecoin issuers; he simultaneously accepted independent-expenditure support from a super-PAC funded by those same issuers and exchanges.
Said

Hagerty serves on the Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee, the chamber's primary venue for stablecoin and digital-asset legislation.

The record shows

Hagerty was a documented beneficiary of Fairshake-network independent expenditures during the 2024 cycle.

Full record →
Contradiction BlackRock Regulatory win Jun 15, 2024
BlackRock's PAC is publicly framed as bipartisan civic participation; the firm simultaneously holds direct fee exposure to specific crypto-policy outcomes (Circle Reserve Fund management plus IBIT issuance) that its lobbying disclosures do not break out as line items.
Said

BlackRock PAC contributes to candidates from both the Democratic and Republican parties

The record shows

Together IBIT and the Circle Reserve Fund give BlackRock direct fee exposure to both the dollar-stablecoin and crypto-asset markets that the GENIUS Act and SAB 121 reversal regulate.

Full record →
Contradiction Circle Internet Financial Regulatory win Jun 15, 2024
Circle's public framing of its lobbying is regulatory clarity for stablecoin users; its own S-1 discloses that the substantial majority of revenue is interest income on reserves — i.e. the legislation it lobbied for protects the yield-extraction business model rather than the consumer-protection goal cited in its public messaging.
Said

Circle publicly campaigned for the repeal of SAB 121 and for passage of the GENIUS Act stablecoin framework, both of which materially expand its addressable market.

The record shows

Circle's S-1 filing disclosed that interest income on reserves accounted for the substantial majority of total revenue, making the company's economics directly geared to short-term U.S. interest rates.

Full record →
Contradiction J. French Hill Direct financial May 22, 2024
Hill's top career donors are banking-sector incumbents; his vote for FIT21 reorganised the digital-asset regulatory regime in a way that materially benefits incumbent banks competing with Coinbase Custody for institutional crypto custody mandates.
Said

Hill's top career contributor is Stephens Inc at $433,140, followed by Bank of New York Mellon ($50,000 in the 2024 cycle alone). His leadership PAC is named In the Arena PAC.

The record shows

Hill voted in favour of H.R.4763 (FIT21) when the bill passed the House on 22 May 2024 with bipartisan support.

Full record →