Said vs. did

What they said, against what the record shows

Every entry pairs a person's own words, dated and sourced, with the record that followed: a filing, a vote, a disclosure, a court position. Five kinds of pairing live in one ledger. Filter by kind, or search a name. For one person's positions over time, see By person.

51entries
35people and companies
5kinds of pairing

Promise vs. footprint: what AI companies promised, against what they disclosed.

5 entries
Promise vs. footprint OpenAI Jan 21, 2025
Altman promised AI would 'fix the climate' — four months later OpenAI announced a $500B / four-year compute build-out, beginning with $100B and a Texas data-center campus
Said

In the next couple of decades, we will be able to do things that would have seemed like magic to our grandparents. AI will contribute to the world by … fixing the climate, establishing a space colony, and the discovery of all of physics. With enough compute,…

Their own disclosure

Today, we're announcing The Stargate Project — a new company that intends to invest $500 billion over the next four years building new AI infrastructure for OpenAI in the United States. We will begin deploying $100 billion immediately. The initial equity…

Full record →
Promise vs. footprint Anthropic Nov 22, 2024
Anthropic's CEO promised AI could compress a century of medical progress into a decade — three weeks later AWS announced a $4B Trainium cluster commitment to support the training
Said

Powerful AI could compress 50 to 100 years of biological and medical progress into 5 to 10 years. AI-accelerated science could solve mental health, eliminate most cancers, prevent most infectious disease, and double the human lifespan. In climate, AI could…

Their own disclosure

AWS and Anthropic deepen strategic collaboration. Anthropic will use AWS Trainium and Trainium2 as its primary training chips, and AWS as its primary cloud and training partner, with $4 billion in additional investment from AWS to support model development…

Full record →
Promise vs. footprint xAI Sep 9, 2024
Musk promised xAI's AGI would deliver "an age of abundance" — months later SELC documented xAI running ~420MW of unpermitted gas turbines in a majority-Black Memphis neighborhood
Said

We're going to have for the first time something smarter than the smartest human. Solve AGI by next year. It will solve all the problems — energy production, water production, food production. We're going to have an age of abundance. (Elon Musk (founder, xAI))

Their own disclosure

Investigation by the Southern Environmental Law Center documented that xAI installed and operated as many as 35 portable methane gas turbines at the South Memphis Colossus data center without applying for Clean Air Act permits. Combined nameplate output of…

Full record →
Promise vs. footprint Google Jul 2, 2024
Google promised AI would help cut 5–10% of global emissions by 2030 — its own 2024 report disclosed AI drove the company's emissions up 48% since 2019
Said

AI has the potential to mitigate 5–10% of global greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 — the equivalent of the annual emissions of the European Union — through optimization of energy grids, transportation routing, and climate-modeling acceleration. (Sundar Pichai…

Their own disclosure

Greenhouse gas emissions in 2023 totalled 14.3 million tonnes CO2e, an increase of 48 percent compared to 2019, primarily driven by increased data center energy consumption and supply chain emissions associated with AI infrastructure build-out.

Full record →
Promise vs. footprint Microsoft May 15, 2024
Microsoft pledged to be carbon-negative by 2030 — four years in, its own 2024 report disclosed emissions are 29.1% above the baseline they promised to cut from
Said

Microsoft will be carbon negative by 2030. By 2050 Microsoft will remove from the environment all the carbon the company has emitted either directly or by electrical consumption since it was founded in 1975. (Brad Smith (President), Satya Nadella (CEO))

Their own disclosure

Our overall emissions increased by 29.1 percent from our 2020 baseline. As we have grown our cloud business, building data centers to deliver AI services has resulted in higher Scope 3 emissions associated with the construction of those data centers, the…

Full record →