Said vs. did

What they said, against what the record shows

Every entry pairs a person's own words, dated and sourced, with the record that followed: a filing, a vote, a disclosure, a court position. Five kinds of pairing live in one ledger. Filter by kind, or search a name. For one person's positions over time, see By person.

51entries
35people and companies
5kinds of pairing
51 entries
Broken promise David G. Valadao violated Jul 3, 2025
David Valadao: signed the April 2025 Medicaid red line, then voted for the cuts
Said

On April 14, 2025, David Valadao was one of twelve House Republicans who signed a letter to Speaker Mike Johnson stating they "will not support a final reconciliation bill that includes any reduction in Medicaid coverage for vulnerable populations."

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, David Valadao voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214) — legislation the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over the following decade and leave…

Full record →
Broken promise Jefferson Van Drew violated Jul 3, 2025
Jefferson Van Drew: signed the April 2025 Medicaid red line, then voted for the cuts
Said

On April 14, 2025, Jefferson Van Drew was one of twelve House Republicans who signed a letter to Speaker Mike Johnson stating they "will not support a final reconciliation bill that includes any reduction in Medicaid coverage for vulnerable populations."

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, Jefferson Van Drew voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214) — legislation the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over the following decade and leave…

Full record →
Broken promise Robert J. Wittman violated Jul 3, 2025
Robert Wittman: signed the April 2025 Medicaid red line, then voted for the cuts
Said

On April 14, 2025, Robert Wittman was one of twelve House Republicans who signed a letter to Speaker Mike Johnson stating they "will not support a final reconciliation bill that includes any reduction in Medicaid coverage for vulnerable populations."

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, Robert Wittman voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214) — legislation the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over the following decade and leave…

Full record →
Broken promise Jennifer A. Kiggans violated Jul 3, 2025
Jennifer Kiggans: signed the April 2025 Medicaid red line, then voted for the cuts
Said

On April 14, 2025, Jennifer Kiggans was one of twelve House Republicans who signed a letter to Speaker Mike Johnson stating they "will not support a final reconciliation bill that includes any reduction in Medicaid coverage for vulnerable populations."

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, Jennifer Kiggans voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214) — legislation the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over the following decade and leave…

Full record →
Broken promise Nick LaLota violated Jul 3, 2025
Nick LaLota: signed the April 2025 Medicaid red line, then voted for the cuts
Said

On April 14, 2025, Nick LaLota was one of twelve House Republicans who signed a letter to Speaker Mike Johnson stating they "will not support a final reconciliation bill that includes any reduction in Medicaid coverage for vulnerable populations."

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, Nick LaLota voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214) — legislation the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over the following decade and leave millions…

Full record →
Broken promise Nicole Malliotakis violated Jul 3, 2025
Nicole Malliotakis: signed the April 2025 Medicaid red line, then voted for the cuts
Said

On April 14, 2025, Nicole Malliotakis was one of twelve House Republicans who signed a letter to Speaker Mike Johnson stating they "will not support a final reconciliation bill that includes any reduction in Medicaid coverage for vulnerable populations."

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, Nicole Malliotakis voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214) — legislation the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over the following decade and leave…

Full record →
Broken promise Dan Newhouse violated Jul 3, 2025
Dan Newhouse: vowed he'd never cut Medicaid, then voted for the cuts
Said

In a March 26, 2025 op-ed in the Yakima Herald-Republic, Rep. Dan Newhouse assured constituents that cutting resources for those who rely on Medicaid, Medicare, and SNAP "is not my aim," framing his goal as curbing improper payments. His hometown paper later…

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, Newhouse voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214), which the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over a decade. Health analysts flagged 14 rural…

Full record →
Broken promise Derrick Van Orden violated Jul 3, 2025
Derrick Van Orden: 'benefits will not be cut,' then voted for the Medicaid cuts
Said

Rep. Derrick Van Orden publicly insisted that "benefits will not be cut" and accused Democrats of "fearmongering" over Medicaid, saying he would "have no part" in cutting the program for the people who depend on it.

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, Van Orden voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214), which the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over the following decade and leave millions more…

Full record →
Broken promise Young Kim violated Jul 3, 2025
Young Kim: signed the April 2025 Medicaid red line, then voted for the cuts
Said

On April 14, 2025, Young Kim was one of twelve House Republicans who signed a letter to Speaker Mike Johnson stating they "will not support a final reconciliation bill that includes any reduction in Medicaid coverage for vulnerable populations."

The record shows

On July 3, 2025, Young Kim voted Yea on H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Roll Call 190, passed 218-214) — legislation the Congressional Budget Office projected would cut roughly $1 trillion from Medicaid over the following decade and leave millions…

Full record →
Said out loud Peter Thiel Humanity Jun 1, 2025
Said

Uh —— … Well, I don't know. I would — I would … there's so many questions implicit in this.

Context The question was: "You would prefer the human race to endure, right?" Douthat had to note, on the record, "You're hesitating," before Thiel eventually answered "Yes" and pivoted to transhumanism — hoping technology will "radically solve" death. The full exchange is in the Times' published transcript; the hesitation itself, from the chairman of a…

Broken promise Sam Altman quietly abandoned May 8, 2025
Altman: ads on ChatGPT would be a 'last resort' — within months OpenAI was hiring for ads
Said

I think ads-on-top-of-AI is a really unfortunate way to monetize … I would consider ads sort of a last resort.

The record shows

OpenAI hires former Meta advertising executive Fidji Simo as 'CEO of Applications', with media reports framing the appointment around ad-led growth.

May 8, 2025 · Reuters, 8 May 2025
Full record →
Said out loud Elon Musk Empathy Feb 28, 2025
Said

The fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy.

Context Musk was describing what he called "suicidal empathy" — a concept he credited to marketing professor Gad Saad — and argued empathy is being "weaponized" as an "exploit" in Western societies, comparing it to a bug in a computer program. He added the qualification: "I believe in empathy, like, I think you should care about other people," but framed the…

Said out loud Donald Trump Rule of Law Feb 15, 2025
Said

He who saves his Country does not violate any Law.

Context A maxim attributed to Napoleon, posted — and pinned — by a sitting president while his administration faced court orders over frozen congressional spending. The White House reposted it on official channels. Posted as a sentence with no context, it asserts exactly what it says: that law does not bind the president when he deems the cause sufficient.

Broken promise Google violated Feb 4, 2025
Google: 'We will not design or deploy AI for weapons'
Said

We will not design or deploy AI in the following application areas: … Weapons or other technologies whose principal purpose or implementation is to cause or directly facilitate injury to people.

The record shows

Google removes the prohibitions against using AI for weapons and surveillance from its public AI Principles page.

Full record →
Said out loud Alex Karp Force Feb 1, 2025
Said

Palantir is here to disrupt and make the institutions we partner with the very best in the world and, when it's necessary, to scare enemies and on occasion kill them.

Context Closing remarks to investors on a quarterly earnings call — not a leaked aside. Karp has repeatedly used similar framing in public ("mostly to kill our enemies," to Axios; adversaries should "wake up scared and go to bed scared"). Palantir holds some of the largest data-integration contracts across U.S. defense, intelligence, and immigration enforcement;…

Court vs. conduct OpenAI Jan 29, 2025
OpenAI defends fair-use scraping of every copyrighted work — while suing over scraping of its own model outputs
Argued in court

Training large language models on the entire public web — including paywalled, copyrighted news articles — is transformative fair use. The model's outputs do not substitute for the original works, and the public benefit of advanced AI outweighs any…

Jan 8, 2024 · courtlistener.com
Then, elsewhere

Users may not 'use Output to develop models that compete with OpenAI'; OpenAI publicly accused DeepSeek of using its model outputs to train competing models in violation of those terms, and is preparing legal action. (OpenAI Terms of Use — Section 2…

Jan 29, 2025 · ft.com

Why it matters OpenAI's fair-use defense in the NYT case turns on the principle that ingesting copyrighted material to train a derivative system that competes with the original is non-infringing because of transformative purpose.…

Full record →
Promise vs. footprint OpenAI Jan 21, 2025
Altman promised AI would 'fix the climate' — four months later OpenAI announced a $500B / four-year compute build-out, beginning with $100B and a Texas data-center campus
Said

In the next couple of decades, we will be able to do things that would have seemed like magic to our grandparents. AI will contribute to the world by … fixing the climate, establishing a space colony, and the discovery of all of physics. With enough compute,…

Their own disclosure

Today, we're announcing The Stargate Project — a new company that intends to invest $500 billion over the next four years building new AI infrastructure for OpenAI in the United States. We will begin deploying $100 billion immediately. The initial equity…

Full record →
Said out loud Marc Andreessen Introspection Jan 1, 2025
Said

Zero. As little as possible. … I find that people who dwell on the past get stuck in the past.

Context His answer to how much time he spends on self-reflection. Andreessen — whose firm's "Techno-Optimist Manifesto" lists "tech ethics" and "risk management" among its enemies — described introspection itself as an early-1900s invention he declines to practice. From one of the most influential capital allocators in AI, "zero introspection" is a governance…

Court vs. conduct Elon Musk Dec 23, 2024
Musk sues OpenAI for abandoning its nonprofit mission — while running xAI as a for-profit on the same playbook
Argued in court

OpenAI's pivot from a charitable, open-source AI research nonprofit to a closed, for-profit subsidiary of Microsoft is a betrayal of its founding charter. The 'capped-profit' structure is a sham that funnels public-good research into private monopoly rents.…

Then, elsewhere

xAI operates as a closed, equity-funded for-profit Delaware corporation, with Musk as majority shareholder, raising $6B at a $50B valuation while marketing its Grok model as a competitor to OpenAI. No nonprofit charter; no open-sourcing of training data,…

Dec 23, 2024 · reuters.com

Why it matters Musk's central legal argument in suing Altman is that AI research of this magnitude should be conducted as a nonprofit, open-source public good, and that pivoting to a closed for-profit structure is itself the harm.…

Full record →
Broken promise OpenAI violated Dec 4, 2024
OpenAI: usage policy bars 'military and warfare' applications
Said

Disallowed usage of our models: … Activity that has high risk of physical harm, including: Weapons development; Military and warfare.

The record shows

OpenAI confirms cybersecurity work with the US Department of Defense; later announces partnership with weapons-maker Anduril.

Full record →