Said vs. did

What they said, against what the record shows

Every entry pairs a person's own words, dated and sourced, with the record that followed: a filing, a vote, a disclosure, a court position. Five kinds of pairing live in one ledger. Filter by kind, or search a name. For one person's positions over time, see By person.

51entries
35people and companies
5kinds of pairing
51 entries
Promise vs. footprint Anthropic Nov 22, 2024
Anthropic's CEO promised AI could compress a century of medical progress into a decade — three weeks later AWS announced a $4B Trainium cluster commitment to support the training
Said

Powerful AI could compress 50 to 100 years of biological and medical progress into 5 to 10 years. AI-accelerated science could solve mental health, eliminate most cancers, prevent most infectious disease, and double the human lifespan. In climate, AI could…

Their own disclosure

AWS and Anthropic deepen strategic collaboration. Anthropic will use AWS Trainium and Trainium2 as its primary training chips, and AWS as its primary cloud and training partner, with $4 billion in additional investment from AWS to support model development…

Full record →
Promise vs. footprint xAI Sep 9, 2024
Musk promised xAI's AGI would deliver "an age of abundance" — months later SELC documented xAI running ~420MW of unpermitted gas turbines in a majority-Black Memphis neighborhood
Said

We're going to have for the first time something smarter than the smartest human. Solve AGI by next year. It will solve all the problems — energy production, water production, food production. We're going to have an age of abundance. (Elon Musk (founder, xAI))

Their own disclosure

Investigation by the Southern Environmental Law Center documented that xAI installed and operated as many as 35 portable methane gas turbines at the South Memphis Colossus data center without applying for Clean Air Act permits. Combined nameplate output of…

Full record →
Said out loud Larry Ellison Surveillance Sep 1, 2024
Said

Citizens will be on their best behavior, because we're constantly recording and reporting everything that is going on.

Context Said approvingly, not as a warning — during an hour-long investor Q&A pitching Oracle's AI infrastructure. Ellison described a future where police body cams, drones, and street cameras feed continuously into AI that "will report that problem to the appropriate person," supervising officers and citizens alike in real time. He was describing a product…

Said out loud Elon Musk Incitement Aug 4, 2024
Said

Civil war is inevitable.

Context Posted under a video of far-right rioting in Liverpool — days after the Southport stabbings, while mobs were attacking hotels housing asylum seekers. Viewed 9.6 million times on the platform he owns and whose amplification rules he sets. The UK Prime Minister's office responded on the record: "There's no justification for comments like that." Musk did not…

Promise vs. footprint Google Jul 2, 2024
Google promised AI would help cut 5–10% of global emissions by 2030 — its own 2024 report disclosed AI drove the company's emissions up 48% since 2019
Said

AI has the potential to mitigate 5–10% of global greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 — the equivalent of the annual emissions of the European Union — through optimization of energy grids, transportation routing, and climate-modeling acceleration. (Sundar Pichai…

Their own disclosure

Greenhouse gas emissions in 2023 totalled 14.3 million tonnes CO2e, an increase of 48 percent compared to 2019, primarily driven by increased data center energy consumption and supply chain emissions associated with AI infrastructure build-out.

Full record →
Contradiction Bill Hagerty Career Jun 15, 2024
Hagerty's seat on Senate Banking is framed as oversight of stablecoin issuers; he simultaneously accepted independent-expenditure support from a super-PAC funded by those same issuers and exchanges.
Said

Hagerty serves on the Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee, the chamber's primary venue for stablecoin and digital-asset legislation.

The record shows

Hagerty was a documented beneficiary of Fairshake-network independent expenditures during the 2024 cycle.

Full record →
Contradiction BlackRock Regulatory win Jun 15, 2024
BlackRock's PAC is publicly framed as bipartisan civic participation; the firm simultaneously holds direct fee exposure to specific crypto-policy outcomes (Circle Reserve Fund management plus IBIT issuance) that its lobbying disclosures do not break out as line items.
Said

BlackRock PAC contributes to candidates from both the Democratic and Republican parties

The record shows

Together IBIT and the Circle Reserve Fund give BlackRock direct fee exposure to both the dollar-stablecoin and crypto-asset markets that the GENIUS Act and SAB 121 reversal regulate.

Full record →
Contradiction Circle Internet Financial Regulatory win Jun 15, 2024
Circle's public framing of its lobbying is regulatory clarity for stablecoin users; its own S-1 discloses that the substantial majority of revenue is interest income on reserves — i.e. the legislation it lobbied for protects the yield-extraction business model rather than the consumer-protection goal cited in its public messaging.
Said

Circle publicly campaigned for the repeal of SAB 121 and for passage of the GENIUS Act stablecoin framework, both of which materially expand its addressable market.

The record shows

Circle's S-1 filing disclosed that interest income on reserves accounted for the substantial majority of total revenue, making the company's economics directly geared to short-term U.S. interest rates.

Full record →
Contradiction J. French Hill Direct financial May 22, 2024
Hill's top career donors are banking-sector incumbents; his vote for FIT21 reorganised the digital-asset regulatory regime in a way that materially benefits incumbent banks competing with Coinbase Custody for institutional crypto custody mandates.
Said

Hill's top career contributor is Stephens Inc at $433,140, followed by Bank of New York Mellon ($50,000 in the 2024 cycle alone). His leadership PAC is named In the Arena PAC.

The record shows

Hill voted in favour of H.R.4763 (FIT21) when the bill passed the House on 22 May 2024 with bipartisan support.

Full record →
Promise vs. footprint Microsoft May 15, 2024
Microsoft pledged to be carbon-negative by 2030 — four years in, its own 2024 report disclosed emissions are 29.1% above the baseline they promised to cut from
Said

Microsoft will be carbon negative by 2030. By 2050 Microsoft will remove from the environment all the carbon the company has emitted either directly or by electrical consumption since it was founded in 1975. (Brad Smith (President), Satya Nadella (CEO))

Their own disclosure

Our overall emissions increased by 29.1 percent from our 2020 baseline. As we have grown our cloud business, building data centers to deliver AI services has resulted in higher Scope 3 emissions associated with the construction of those data centers, the…

Full record →
Broken promise Elon Musk violated Apr 26, 2024
Musk: Tesla will drive itself coast-to-coast with no human input by end of 2017
Said

I am very confident that we will be able to do a demonstration drive of full autonomy from LA to New York by the end of the year. So basically, you'll be able to get in the car, go to sleep, and wake up at your destination.

Oct 19, 2016 · Reuters, 19 October 2016
The record shows

NHTSA opens an investigation after a fatal Autopilot crash; FSD remains supervised seven years after the promised deadline.

Apr 26, 2024 · Reuters, 26 April 2024
Full record →
Broken promise Sam Bankman-Fried violated Mar 28, 2024
Bankman-Fried: 'FTX has enough to cover all client holdings. We don't invest client assets.'
Said

FTX has enough to cover all client holdings. We don't invest client assets (even in treasuries). We have been processing all withdrawals, and will continue to be.

The record shows

Bankman-Fried convicted on all seven counts of fraud and conspiracy; sentenced to 25 years in prison.

Full record →
Court vs. conduct Palantir Technologies Mar 13, 2024
Palantir sues to protect its source code as trade-secret — markets its platform as 'auditable' and 'transparent' to government clients
Argued in court

Palantir's source code, ranking algorithms, and data-model schemas are protected trade secrets. Disclosure — even under court-ordered protective order — would cause irreparable competitive harm. Confidentiality clauses must override any third-party…

Oct 21, 2019 · courtlistener.com
Then, elsewhere

Marketing position: Palantir Foundry/Gotham provides 'auditability', 'transparency', and 'civil-liberties protections' that justify entrusting it with NHS patient records, IRS taxpayer files, and ICE detention data. The same platform whose code is a sealed…

Mar 13, 2024 · committees.parliament.uk

Why it matters Palantir's commercial-litigation posture is that its software is so proprietary and confidential that even a federal court cannot compel meaningful disclosure of how its ranking and matching algorithms work. Its…

Full record →
Said out loud Erik Prince Empire Feb 1, 2024
Said

It's time for us to just put the imperial hat back on, to say, we're going to govern those countries … 'cause enough is enough, we're done being invaded.

Context Prince was arguing the U.S. should directly govern "incapable" countries in Africa and Latin America. When his co-host warned listeners would call that colonialism, Prince answered: "Absolutely, yes." From a man who builds and sells private armies — including pitches to do exactly this kind of work — it reads less as provocation than as a business plan.…

Said out loud Marc Andreessen Ethics Oct 16, 2023
Said

We have enemies. Our enemies are not bad people – but rather bad ideas.

Context The manifesto's own "The Enemy" section then names the ideas: a "mass demoralization campaign" waged "against technology and against life" under the names "existential risk," "sustainability," "ESG," "social responsibility," "stakeholder capitalism," "trust and safety," "tech ethics," "risk management," and "de-growth." The document declaring safety teams…

Broken promise Mark Zuckerberg violated May 22, 2023
Zuckerberg to Congress: 'You should have complete control over your data'
Said

Across the board, we have a responsibility to not just build tools, but to make sure those tools are used for good. … You should have complete control over your data.

The record shows

EU Data Protection Commission fines Meta €1.2 billion for unlawful transfers of European users' personal data.

Full record →
Broken promise ExxonMobil violated Jan 13, 2023
ExxonMobil: 'The science is uncertain' — while internal scientists confirmed warming
Said

Currently, the scientific evidence is inconclusive as to whether human activities are having a significant effect on the global climate.

The record shows

Exxon's internal scientific projections from 1977 to 2003 are shown in Science to have been highly accurate predictions of warming — contradicting decades of public-facing doubt.

Full record →
Court vs. conduct ExxonMobil Jan 13, 2023
Exxon tells courts the science is uncertain — while internal scientists modeled warming with high accuracy
Argued in court

Public-facing position throughout the 1990s–2000s: 'the scientific evidence is inconclusive as to whether human activities are having a significant effect on the global climate.' Exxon argued in defense filings that its statements were protected…

Oct 24, 2019 · mass.gov
Then, elsewhere

Exxon's own scientists, in internal memos, accurately projected the magnitude and rate of human-caused warming decades before the public statements that called the same science 'inconclusive'. The peer-reviewed analysis shows the internal projections tracked…

Jan 13, 2023 · science.org

Why it matters Exxon's defense to state-level consumer-protection suits is that climate science was genuinely uncertain when it told the public it was uncertain — i.e., a good-faith reading of the science at the time. The Supran et…

Full record →
Said out loud Sam Altman AI Risk Jan 1, 2023
Said

The bad case — and I think this is important to say — is, like, lights out for all of us.

Context His own answer, as OpenAI's CEO, to the worst-case scenario for the technology his company leads the race to build. He added that he is "more worried about an accidental misuse case in the short term" and stressed safety and alignment work. The entry pairs with his 2015 quip above: a decade apart, the stated downside has stayed "the end of the world" while…